Community authority over Indigenous data
Applies to all data about Aboriginal and Torres Strait Islander peoples, communities, Country and knowledge, whatever its classification level.
The organisation recognises that the community the data is about holds authority over it, acting through the people that community nominates. Decisions to collect, use, share, keep or destroy the data are made or approved by that authority, not by the organisation alone.
Rationale: Indigenous peoples have rights and interests in data about them, their Country and their knowledge. Without a named authority, the organisation that holds the data ends up deciding for the community by default.
| Maturity Level | Required Implementation Descriptor |
|---|---|
| IDG-ML0 | Not in place, or does not yet satisfy IDG-ML1. |
| IDG-ML1 | The organisation keeps a register of which communities its Indigenous data relates to and who each community has nominated to decide about it. |
| IDG-ML2 | Every decision to collect, use, share or destroy Indigenous data has a recorded approval from the community's nominated people before it takes effect. |
| IDG-ML3 | Systems refuse an action that has no current community approval, and the community can review every decision made under its authority. |
Evidence types: register, meeting_record, agreement, system_check
Maiam nayri Wingara: control (Exercise control of the data ecosystem including creation, development, stewardship, analysis, dissemination and infrastructure.); accountable (Data structures that are accountable to Indigenous peoples and First Nations.)
BlakSmith worked example: A record under a cultural protocol names its custodian groups. Only a person with an approved membership of one of those groups can open it. Membership is a relationship to the group, not a system role.
Honest gaps: When a custodian group has no active approved member, two owners or admins can bootstrap its first members citing a record of the group decision (never an owner or admin), and those memberships stay provisional pending community confirmation (issue #286). Once a group has an active member, only its approved members decide membership. Decisions to collect, use, share or destroy data are not all recorded as community approvals; that evidence is manual outside data sharing agreement sign-offs.
Framework crosswalks & departures (8)
- TRUST Principles for digital repositories
user-focuspartial TRUST asks repositories to meet the norms of their user communities, which can include the people the data is about. It does not give anyone authority over the data. IDG gives that authority to the community the data is about. - Framework for Governance of Indigenous Data
G1partial The Framework asks agencies to partner with Aboriginal and Torres Strait Islander people at every stage of the data lifecycle. IDG-GOV-001 goes further on authority: the community the data is about decides, rather than sharing the decision with the organisation. The governance committees and paying partners in actions G1.2 to G1.4 are mapped to IDG-GOV-005, not to this control. - Framework for Governance of Indigenous Data
G3.4supports Noting where people can take part is narrower than IDG-GOV-001, which needs the community's approval at each of those points. - NIST Cybersecurity Framework (CSF) 2.0 no equivalent Security frameworks give authority to the organisation that holds the data. None gives it to the community the data is about.
- Information Security Manual (ISM) no equivalent Security frameworks give authority to the organisation that holds the data. None gives it to the community the data is about.
- Privacy Act 1988: Australian Privacy Principles and the Notifiable Data Breaches scheme no equivalent The Australian Privacy Principles protect individuals. They do not recognise collective authority over data.
- FAIR Guiding Principles for scientific data management and stewardship no equivalent FAIR is about making data reusable. It does not say who holds authority over the data. CARE was written to fill that gap.
- ISO/IEC 38505-1: Governance of data, application of ISO/IEC 38500 to the governance of data no equivalent ISO/IEC 38505-1 makes the organisation's governing body accountable for the organisation's use of data. None of the paraphrased entries (see crosswalk-gaps.md) gives authority to the community the data is about. IDG puts that community above the governing body for decisions about its data, and gives the governing body no cultural authority.